I was a big fan of The Transformers growing up. I remember it was a priority for me to get to a TV every afternoon back in 1984 to get my fix of the cartoon and later I would pore over the latest Transformers comics.
Non-fans may be surprised to know that the comic franchise continues today, published by IDW comics. Not bad for a 25 year old toy.
Today the live-action version of Transformers is reinvigorating the franchise; new toys, new fans, and reignition of nostalgia for old fans like me. Thanks to the new movie release apparently some of the license holders of the Transformers brand decided to release remastered cartoons of the first season of Transformers on DVD. My wife and son picked it up for me for Father's Day.
I knew there's going to be some inevitable nostalgia rot. I have fond memories of the stuff I liked...but as I grew up the cringing parts sort of disappeared. Now they're captured in detail on DVD for me to relive and wonder, "What the hell was I thinking?"
There were technical mistakes. Color mismatches. Characters that aren't supposed to be there right in the scene ("Where's Bumblebee?" He's standing three feet behind you. Suddenly he's driving up to the group. Whoops.) In the first episodes the Autobots fly. In the third episode, Optimus takes a rocket pack from Sideswipe to fly after escaping Decepticons. So...can you fly, or not?
There were obvious mistakes in science and logic. One episode had Decepticons getting energy by stealing it from some crystal from the Earth's core (Fire in the Sky). As they extracted it the Earth cooled...um...our planet surface isn't primarily heated from the heat in the core, I'm afraid. It would make it hard to stand outside. And how do you have a forty foot robot transform into a handgun?
There's the plain weird...in the first season of The Transformers, I think the easiest way to cripple an autobot in car or truck mode is to tip him over. Every time someone is blown down a hillside or onto their side, someone has to step in to put them back upright before they're asked if they can transform. I'm surprised they don't all transform into turtles.
There were philosophical errors. Optimus believes in sanctity of life and freedom. They made the dinobots, and on the first activation the three Dinobots go on a rampage and "destroy" equipment before being stopped. So naturally, believing in the inalienable rights of all beings, he orders them deactivated forever and stuck into a collapsed cavern. Naturally the Autobots get into trouble, Wheeljack enhances the intelligence of the Dinobots enough that they are sent out to save the day, and now that they're suddenly beneficial to them Optimus graciously allows them to join the Autobot ranks. That's a nice message to send kids...if you're useful, you can live. But we're the good guys.
Which segues into the error of stereotypical cliche's. There is no depth of character; the beings are either good or evil. It's pretty clear cut. The bad guy wants to rule the universe. Why? No one knows. The good guy is entirely consumed by just stopping the bad guy. What happens if the bad guy is stopped? No one knows. Cartoon Optimus would have no purpose if not for that one goal. They're robots...giant computers...yet apparently computers that can't aim since most of their shots miss wildly. If someone's shot, they're fixed within ten minutes if it's not vital to the storyline that the character is mortally wounded. They're apparently not very good with building weapons either since we lowly humans have weapons that will level a city, while these four-story mechanical beings with interstellar travel have weapons that make little pops and sparks and the guy hit grunts a little big before getting back up and declaring himself injured, but would be okay.
There's even the GI Joe cartoon cliche of specialization. Every Transformer has a weapon that does something special. Starscream has null-rays. Megatron's fusion cannon. Who is building these weapons, themselves? They're weapons specialists and manufacturers? Shouldn't they just have a generic gun that just blows the limbs off each other? GI Joe took it one step further...when the one guy on the whole force that specialized in cold-weather fighting has a cold or breaks a limb, apparently the Joes just have to sit back while COBRA executes their latest scheme in the arctic.
But I still loved it.
I think it comes from the cartoon being a platform on which to hitch dreams. The idea of giant robots from another planet that can shift and fold into everyday objects was just plain cool. What if we could transform? Or had friends that were giant robots that could take us places? Wouldn't it be handier than having Mom and Dad hauling us to the mall? Of course the reason for all the shortcomings becomes crystal clear when you realize that as far as the company behind Transformers was concerned, the cartoon and comics were vehicles to sales. Sales slump, they introduce new robots. When The Powers That Be wanted to push sales of a new line of revamped toys they released the 1986 animated movie where many of the key characters...including Optimus Prime...were killed off. Supposedly the execs behind the movie were bewildered at the ensuing backlash they received from fans (they had actual emotional ties to these characters? No way...) (see links here and here).
Transformers obviously struck a chord in many of us as the franchise made enough money that it is still around today. More importantly the initial wave of Transformers had an audience that was static; as we grew up, so did the series. Only not as cartoons. As comics. (Okay, once there was enough of a chasm that the audience of the original series were having their own series, there were inevitable "reimagines" of Transformers like Beast Wars and Transformers Animated...ugh...).
My wife is a big critic of the cartoons from the early years. She finds them shallow and silly with inane dialog that appeals to the most childish of the childish, and I can't say I don't entirely disagree while re-watching the series. But I also handed her a copy of the Transformers Spotlight comic centered on Cliffjumper; a little red transformer that was almost looked like a brother to Bumblebee on the series (the toys were just repaints of each other) and was voiced on the cartoon by Casey Kasem. In the comic, Cliffjumper was stranded on a planet when his ship "had trouble". He befriended a sister and brother left parentless, and he helped around their farm. Eventually some Decepticons appeared and he dispatches three of them before they call for reinforcements and take the native friends hostage; Cliffjumper gives himself up to spare his friends, but in a turn...let's just say that you don't cross Cliffjumper. My wife's height of compliment was to say that she thought it was okay...which for a story about a cartoon series robot, is saying quite a bit. There are nuances in the comic that show more development you'd never see in the cartoons, such as when the flesh-and-blood friends ask Cliffjumper if he hurt other people and he refused to answer...he was an assassin, and the television series would never even allow the phrase "I'm going to kill you" to be uttered. The line between pure good and pure evil is made murky in these stories and makes the story more real in the process.
There have been other comic storylines that flesh out actual characters of dimension; the Megatron Origins series depicts Megatron as becoming a defacto leader of the Decepticons after the Autobot government basically opresses segments of the people and Megatron was an energon miner who traveled down a road of rebellion; he accidentally kills someone during an uprising and escapes imprisonment to fight in the underground gladiatorial arena where his skills were admired and honed. After reading that one I could almost sympathize with Megatron and his desire to kill all the Autobots.
Now the entire franchise has been rebooted with the live-action movie. I wasn't a huge fan of the new movies at first; since then the background has gradually been augmented with more background information and backstory from comic prequels (Alliance and Defiance, as well as a Reign of Starscream from just after the first movie). I've come to enjoy the film franchise as it stands in its own right. I still miss seeing the Dinobots, though. In another way I'm glad not to see them in the film. I'm afraid of what they'd have done to them and I kind of liked the characters as they were in the comics.
Transgene-Free Gene Editing in Plants
14 hours ago